1950 — Marion Motley (UP, AP), Mac Speedie (UP), Bill Willis (UP). 1951 — Tony Adamle (UP), Frank Gatski (UP, AP), Otto Graham (UP, AP), Lou Groza (UP), Dub Jones (UP, AP), Dante Lavelli (UP). 1952 — Len Ford (UP, AP), Frank Gatski (AP), Otto Graham (UP), Lou Groza (UP, AP), Mac Speedie (UP), Bill Willis (UP, AP). 1953 — Len Ford (UP, AP), Frank Gatski (UP, AP), Ken Gorgal (UP), Otto Graham (UP, AP), Lou Groza (UP, AP), Dante Lavelli (UP), Tommy Thompson (UP), Bill Willis (AP). 1954 — Len Ford (UP, AP, NEA), Abe Gibron (NEA), Otto Graham (UP, AP), Lou Groza (UP, AP, NEA), John Kissell (NEA). 1955 — Don Colo (UP, NEA), Len Ford (UP, NEA), Frank Gatski (UP, AP, NEA), Abe Gibron (UP, NEA), Otto Graham (UP, AP), Lou Groza (UP, AP, NEA), Don Paul (UP). 1956 — None. 1957 — Jim Brown (UP, AP, NEA), Don Colo (NEA), Lou Groza (UP) Mike McCormack (NEA). 1958 — Jim Brown (UPI, AP, NEA), Bob Gain (NEA). 1959 — Jim Brown (UPI, AP, NEA), Jim Ray Smith (UPI, AP, NEA).
1960 — Jim Brown (UPI, AP, NEA), Jim Ray Smith (UPI, AP, NEA). 1961 — Jim Brown (UPI, AP, NEA), Jim Ray Smith (UPI, AP, NEA). 1962 — Jim Ray Smith (NEA). 1963 — Jim Brown (UPI, AP, NEA), Dick Schafrath (AP). 1964 — Jim Brown (UPI, AP, NEA), Jim Houston (NEA), Dick Schafrath (AP, UPI), Paul Warfield (NEA). 1965 — Jim Brown (UPI, AP, NEA), Gary Collins (UPI), Jim Houston (UPI), Dick Schafrath (UPI, AP). 1966 — Gene Hickerson (NEA), Leroy Kelly (UPI, AP, NEA). 1967 — Gene Hickerson (AP, NEA, UPI), Leroy Kelly (AP, NEA, UPI). 1968 — Gene Hickerson (AP, NEA, UPI), Leroy Kelly (AP, NEA, UPI), Paul Warfield (NEA, UPI). 1969 — Gary Collins (AP, UPI), Gene Hickerson (AP, UPI), Leroy Kelly (NEA), Paul Warfield (NEA).
1970 — Gene Hickerson (UPI, PFWA). 1971 — Leroy Kelly (NEA). 1972 — Don Cockroft (NEA). 1973 — Clarence Scott (UPI). 1974 — None. 1975 — None.1976 — Jerry Sherk (AP, NEA, PFWA). 1977 — None. 1978 — Thom Darden (NEA, PFWA). 1979 — Ozzie Newsome (PFWA).
1980 — Lyle Alzado (AP, UPI), Joe DeLamielleure (NEA, PFWA, UPI), Brian Sipe (AP, PFWA, NEA, UPI). 1981 — None. 1982 — None. 1983 — Chip Banks (AP, PFWA). 1984 — Clay Matthews (NEA), Ozzie Newsome (AP, NEA, PFWA). 1985 — None. 1986 — Chip Banks (UPI, AP), Hanford Dixon (AP, PFWA, NEA, UPI), Dan Fike (NEA), Bob Golic (AP, NEA), Frank Minnifield (UPI). 1987 — Hanford Dixon (AP, NEA, PFWA, UPI), Frank Minnifield (AP, NEA, PFWA, UPI), Bernie Kosar (UPI), Earnest Byner (UPI), Dan Fike (UPI), Carl Hairston (UPI), Cody Risien (UPI). 1988 — Hanford Dixon (AP), Frank Minnifield (AP, NEA, PFWA, UPI), Clay Matthews (UPI). 1989 — Mike Johnson (UPI), Frank Minnifield (AP, UPI), Clay Matthews (UPI), Michael Dean Perry (AP, UPI, PFWA), Webster Slaughter (AP, UPI).
1990 — Michael Dean Perry (AP, UPI, PFWA, NEA). 1991 — Michael Dean Perry (AP, USA, NEA). 1992 — None. 1993 — Eric Metcalf (AP, PFWA, UPI). 1994 — Rob Burnett (UPI) Pepper Johnson (UPI, USA), Tony Jones (AP), Michael Dean Perry (AP, UPI), Matt Stover (UPI), Eric Turner (AP, PFWA, UPI). 1995 — None. 1999 — None.
2000 — Chris Gardocki (AP Second Team). 2001 — Jamir Miller (AP, College and Pro Football Weekly, Football Digest, Pro Football Weekly, Sports Illustrated, Sporting News). 2002 — None. 2003 — None. 2004 — None. 2005 — None. 2006 — None. 2007 — Phil Dawson (AP Second Team), Joshua Cribbs (PFWA, Sporting News, AP 2nd Team), Braylon Edwards (Sporting News, AP Second Team), Joe Thomas (PFWA All-Rookie). 2008 — Joshua Cribbs (Sports Illustrated), Joe Thomas (AP 2nd Team). 2009 — Blake Costanzo (Sports Illustrated), Joshua Cribbs (AP 1st Team, PFWA, Sports Illustrated), Alex Mack (PFWA All-Rookie), Joe Thomas (AP 1st Team, PFWA, Sports Illustrated).
2010 — Joe Haden (PFWA All-Rookie), Alex Mack (Sports Illustrated), Joe Thomas (AP 1st Team, PFWA, Sporting News), T.J. Ward (PFWA All-Rookie, PFWA Rookie Special Teamer). 2011 — Jabaal Sheard (PFWA All-Rookie), Phil Taylor (PFWA All-Rookie), Joe Thomas (AP 1st Team, PFWA, Sports Illustrated). 2012 — Johnson Bademosi (PFWA Rookie Special Teamer), Phil Dawson (AP 2nd Team), Mitchell Schwartz (PFWA All-Rookie), Joe Thomas (AP 2nd Team), T.J. Ward (Sports Illustrated). 2013 — Jordan Cameron (PFWA All-AFC Team), Josh Gordon (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team), Joe Haden (AP 2nd Team, PFWA All-AFC Team), Alex Mack (AP 2nd Team, PFWA All-AFC Team), Joe Thomas (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team), T.J. Ward (AP 2nd team). 2014 — Joel Bitonio (PFWA All-AFC Team, PFWA All-Rookie Team), Joe Thomas (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team). 2015 — Alex Mack (PFWA All-AFC Team), Joe Thomas (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team). 2016 — Joe Thomas (PFWA All-NFL Team). 2018 — Joel Bitonio (AP 2nd Team), Myles Garrett (AP 2nd Team, PFWA All-AFC Team), Baker Mayfield (PFWA Rookie of the Year, PFWA All-Rookie Team), Denzel Ward (PFWA All-Rookie Team). 2019 — Joel Bitonio (AP 2nd Team), Nick Chubb (PFWA All-AFC Team), Jamie Gillan (PFWA All-Rookie Team), Austin Seibert (PFWA All-Rookie Team).
2020 — Jack Conklin (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team), Myles Garrett (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team), Joel Bitonio (AP 2nd Team, PFWA All-NFL Team), Wyatt Teller (AP 2nd Team), Jedrick Wills Jr. (PFWA All-Rookie Team). 2021 — Nick Chubb (PFWA All-NFL Team, PFWA All-AFC Team), Myles Garrett (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team, PFWA All-AFC Team), Joel Bitonio (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team, PFWA All-AFC Team), Wyatt Teller (AP 2nd Team), Demetric Felton (PFWA All-Rookie Team), CB Greg Newsome (PFWA All-Rookie Team), Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah (PFWA All-Rookie Team). 2022 — Joel Bitonio (AP 1st Team, PWFA All-NFL Team, PFWA All-AFC Team), Nick Chubb (AP 2nd Team, PFWA All-NFL Team, PFWA All-AFC Team), Myles Garrett (AP 2nd Team, PFWA All-NFL Team, PFWA All-AFC Team). 2023 — Myles Garrett (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team, PFWA All-AFC Team), Dawand Jones (PFWA All-Rookie Team). 2024 - Myles Garrett (AP 1st Team, PFWA All-NFL Team, PFWA All-AFC Team)